Best shoes
9 best shoes for New York in September
highs of 76°F, lows of 61°F, 9 rainy days — here's what to put on your feet.
Why these shoes for New York in September
New York in September averages highs around 76°F, lows near 61°F, 9 rainy days.
New York is a pure walking city — subway stairs and long blocks punish weak cushioning. Expect long walking days in New York: flat pavement is kind to most walking shoes.
Plan on two pairs — one built for the weather extremes and a lighter backup for evenings and dry stretches.
Our picks focus on everyday sneakers, walking shoes, slip-ons — enough range to cover day-to-day walking without overpacking.
How many pairs?
Pack two pairs
Recommendation: 2 pairs
- Primary: waterproof or water-resistant pair for wet sidewalks.
- Backup: drier/lighter pair for dinners and transit.
Best everyday sneakers for New York in September
ForecastStyle pick
Grey Summit Chunky Trail Sneakers
A rugged sole provides superior traction on and off the trail, while the cushioned interior ensures all-day comfort. The chunky silhouett…
Shop on Amazon →
ForecastStyle pick
Black Minimal Leather Everyday Sneakers
Matte black leather everyday sneakers with a slim profile that works for flights and dinners. A quiet sole and soft lining keep them comf…
Shop on Amazon →
ForecastStyle pick
Olive Green Everyday Low Sneakers
Muted olive low sneakers that pair with neutrals and denim. A low-profile everyday option when white feels too high-maintenance.
Shop on Amazon →Best walking shoes for New York in September
ForecastStyle pick
All-Terrain Trail Runner Sneaker in Mint
A lightweight and durable sneaker designed for rugged terrain and everyday wear. The cushioned sole and breathable upper provide all-day …
Shop on Amazon →
ForecastStyle pick
The Everyday Cloud Sneaker in White
A flexible knit upper and cushioned insole provide all-day comfort for travel days, commutes, or weekend errands. Pairs effortlessly with…
Shop on Amazon →
ForecastStyle pick
Olive Water-Resistant Packable Trail Sneakers
Olive water-resistant trail-to-city sneakers with a light pack weight. Subtle traction for wet plazas without heavy hiking bulk.
Shop on Amazon →Best slip-on shoes for New York in September
ForecastStyle pick
Cozy Knit Slip-On Sneakers in Black
A sock-like knit upper hugs your foot for all-day comfort. The cushioned sole makes them perfect for weekend errands or travel days.
Shop on Amazon →
Cream
Cream Knit Everyday Sneakers
Cream knit everyday sneakers that breathe on warm days and slip on easily for security. Soft sock-like upper with a cushioned footbed for…
Shop on Amazon →
ForecastStyle pick
The Everyday Chunky Lug-Sole Loafer
A modern take on a classic silhouette, these loafers feature a substantial lug sole for all-day comfort and traction. They effortlessly e…
Shop on Amazon →Full New York fall style guide — outfits beyond shoes
Style Guide
New York Fall 2026 Packing Guide
Pack smart for a stylish, weather-proof trip to New York in fall
Wear them with these outfits
Climate-matched looks for New York in September.
Previous month
New York in August
Next month
New York in October
Full packing list
New York in September
Outfit ideas
New York in September
All months
Best shoes for New York
Pack or skip
Umbrella for September?
Similar climate
Bayside in September
Similar climate
Porto in September
Similar climate
Denver in September
Packing Calculator
How many outfits do you actually need?
Free · no sign-up needed
Stay ready
Get shoe & packing tips for New York
Occasional destination notes — no spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
FAQ
Are waterproof shoes necessary in New York in September?
Probably worth it — about 9 rainy days on average. Water-resistant will do; full waterproof is overkill.
Do I need boots in New York in September?
Not really — average lows near 61°F stay above the boot threshold. A supportive sneaker is enough.
Can I wear sandals in New York in September?
Yes, for midday. Highs around 76°F are on the edge, so plan a backup for cooler mornings and evenings.
Can I get by with one pair of shoes in New York in September?
Many travelers do fine with one strong walking pair. Add a second only if you need dress shoes or a wet-weather dedicated option.
What about dressy dinners in New York?
Most cities accept clean sneakers or light boots for smart-casual dinners. If you have a black-tie night, pack one dress shoe and wear your walking pair on the plane.
Any tips for packing shoes for New York?
Wear the bulkiest pair on the plane, stuff socks into the packed pair, and use a shoe bag so damp soles do not ruin clothes. Pack a thin spare pair of socks for rainy days.